Page 19 of 390 FirstFirst ... 917181920212969119 ... LastLast
Results 451 to 475 of 9731

Thread: EB2-3 Predictions (Rather Calculations) 2015-2020

  1. #451

    H1 -> j1

    My observations are anecdotal. Are you referring to your H1-B or did your wife apply for H1-B as well?

    I know of multiple spouses who were on H4 and then ported to J1. I have not heard of 1 case that got rejected because they or their spouse were on H1. So, any increased risk should be miniscule. Irrespective of whether you have a kid or not. Most of those who applied to J1 went through consular processing. So, I cannot comment on length of time for change of status.

    Congrats to your wife on her residency. And all the best.

    Quote Originally Posted by unknownindian1 View Post
    Moderator: I apologize if this is the wrong forum. If so, please move to the appropriate thread (I did not see any thread of J1)

    I need some help urgently. I am on H1B (EB3 - I140 approved, PD Sep 2009; Applied for EB2 Dec 2013 - hoping for a decision soon ) and my wife is on H4. She got her residency and needs to start working 1st July, 2015. Her program did not provide her H1B sponsorship and needs to apply for J1. We have started the process. However, I heard from multiple lawyers that she has got higher chance of rejection of J1 visa since I have applied for H1 B and we already have a daughter born here. Also, I heard that she should do consular processing (and not change of status) since change of status take a long time. Is there any way to find the rejection rates of J1 visa and what is the best way to reduce the chance of J1 rejection? Thanks

  2. #452
    Guru Spectator's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    A Galaxy Far far Away
    Posts
    3,337
    I hinted my previous calculation was quite aggressive, so here is a repeat of that, plus a conservative calculation and the mean of the two calculations.

    AGGRESSIVE
    Country/Group -- EB2 --- EB3

    CHINA ---------- 80% --- 20%
    INDIA ---------- 84% --- 16%
    MEXICO --------- 54% --- 46%
    PHILIPPINES ---- 57% --- 43%
    ROW ------------ 74% --- 26%

    Overall -------- 80% --- 20%


    CONSERVATIVE
    Country/Group -- EB2 --- EB3

    CHINA ---------- 78% --- 22%
    INDIA ---------- 77% --- 23%
    MEXICO --------- 45% --- 55%
    PHILIPPINES ---- 50% --- 50%
    ROW ------------ 69% --- 31%

    Overall -------- 74% --- 26%


    MEAN
    Country/Group -- EB2 --- EB3

    CHINA ---------- 79% --- 21%
    INDIA ---------- 81% --- 19%
    MEXICO --------- 49% --- 51%
    PHILIPPINES ---- 53% --- 47%
    ROW ------------ 71% --- 29%

    Overall -------- 77% --- 23%

    It might also be possible that, comparatively, more "EB2" PERM do not make it through the I-140 stage.

    At some point, it is probably worth looking at the figures net of the large number of CTS certifications in March to see if they have skewed the Indian %.

    EDIT:- CTS certifications had a ratio of 52:48 for EB2:EB3 on the conservative basis.
    Excluding the CTS certifications would increase the conservative India ratio to 89:11 and the overall ratio to 82:18.

    As before, I warn people that these figures should be taken with a large pinch of salt.
    Without an irritant, there can be no pearl.

  3. #453
    Guru Spectator's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    A Galaxy Far far Away
    Posts
    3,337
    Quote Originally Posted by unknownindian1 View Post
    Moderator: I apologize if this is the wrong forum. If so, please move to the appropriate thread (I did not see any thread of J1)

    I need some help urgently. I am on H1B (EB3 - I140 approved, PD Sep 2009; Applied for EB2 Dec 2013 - hoping for a decision soon ) and my wife is on H4. She got her residency and needs to start working 1st July, 2015. Her program did not provide her H1B sponsorship and needs to apply for J1. We have started the process. However, I heard from multiple lawyers that she has got higher chance of rejection of J1 visa since I have applied for H1 B and we already have a daughter born here. Also, I heard that she should do consular processing (and not change of status) since change of status take a long time. Is there any way to find the rejection rates of J1 visa and what is the best way to reduce the chance of J1 rejection? Thanks
    I believe it is quite possible to get a COS to J1. I have no idea of the rejection rate or the circumstance that might lead to a rejection.

    As an important aside, I generally equate the words "residency" and "J1" with the the possibility of a 2 year HRR.

    I hope you have enquired about this and understand if there any implications for your wife.

    If the J1 comes with a 2 year HRR, your wife will be ineligible to return to H4, obtain an H1B, or immigrant status until she has either served the 2 year HRR, or obtained a waiver from it.

    The 2 year HRR is also called 212(e) from the INA. Here is what it says:

    (e) No person admitted under section 101(a)(15)(J) or acquiring such status after admission

    (i) whose participation in the program for which he came to the United States was financed in whole or in part, directly or indirectly, by an agency of the Government of the United States or by the government of the country of his nationality or his last residence,

    (ii) who at the time of admission or acquisition of status under section 101(a)(15)(J) was a national or resident of a country which the Director of the United States Information Agency pursuant to regulations prescribed by him, had designated as clearly requiring the services of persons engaged in the field of specialized knowledge or skill in which the alien was engaged, or

    (iii) who came to the United States or acquired such status in order to receive graduate medical education or training,

    shall be eligible to apply for an immigrant visa, or for permanent residence, or for a nonimmigrant visa under section 101(a)(15)(H) or section 101(a)(15)(L)

    until it is established that such person has resided and been physically present in the country of his nationality or his last residence for an aggregate of a least two years following departure from the United States:

    Provided, That upon the favorable recommendation of the Director, pursuant to the request of an interested United States Government agency (or, in the case of an alien described in clause (iii), pursuant to the request of a State Department of Public Health, or its equivalent), or of the Com missioner of Immigration and Naturalization after he has determined that departure from the United States would impose exceptional hardship upon the alien's spouse or child (if such spouse or child is a citizen of the United States or a lawfully resident alien), or that the alien cannot return to the country of his nationality or last residence because he would be subject to persecution on account of race, religion, or political opinion, the Attorney General may waive the requirement of such two-year foreign residence abroad in the case of any alien whose admission to the United States is found by the Attorney General to be in the public interest except that in the case of a waiver requested by a State Department of Public Health, or its equivalent, or in the case of a waiver requested by an interested United States government agency on behalf of an alien described in clause (iii), the waiver shall be subject to the requirements of section 214(l) :

    And provided further, That, except in the case of an alien described in clause (iii), the Attorney General may, upon the favorable recommendation of the Director, waive such two-year foreign residence requirement in any case in which the foreign country of the alien's nationality or last residence has furnished the Director a statement in writing that it has no objection to such waiver in the case of such alien.
    I'm sure you have considered this, but I mention it anyway, given that your PD is likely to become current under EB2 within the next 18 months at most.

    Apologies in advance if I am way off base.
    Without an irritant, there can be no pearl.

  4. #454
    Quote Originally Posted by jimmys View Post
    Great man. Let's be in touch in this forum.

    Coming back to the point, the way I understood is, you can apply for EAD with future date. I believed it's same with H-4 too. That is, starting from Nov 11. My plan was to apply COS to H-4 and EAD almost together with future date. Say for example, if you're on L-1 visa and apply for H-1B your H-1B starts only from Oct 1. Like the same way, the H-4 starts only at a future date, say, Nov 11,2015. Can't the EAD be filed/approved starting from Nov 11,2015.?

    Can't this be done? Should I wait for her to come back on H-4 first?

    Having a break and moving to H-4 before filing EAD is vanilla case.
    I am not sure how this future start date will pan out. What I read is that USCIS will only start working on the EAD application after COS is approved. Even if we do apply on May 26 without wasting any time, I was thinking that both COS and getting EAD may not be possible within 5 months.

    I will wait to hear others thoughts on this.

  5. #455

    New Update

    Sorry If I should not post other web sites content here.

    From OH Law http://www.immigration-law.com/
    ---------------

    04/20/2015: Movement of EB-2 India Cut-Off Date Predicted "Slow-Down" in August and/or September 2015

    According to the AILA. State Department predicts that the late trend of movement of EB-2 cut-off date for India is likely to slow down as it enters the last quarter of FY 2015. It is likely that the cut-off date for India EB-2 may continuously move ahead a few months in June and July.

    From Ron http://www.immigration-information.c...penheim.17997/
    -----------
    This is from AILA's meeting with him on 4/16/2015:

    EB-2 India. After advancing 16 months in March 2015, and eight months in April, EB-2 India will advance another 7+ months in May, to April 15, 2008. As cautioned last month, members should not expect that this category will continue to advance at this pace beyond July, and should expect it to slow or stop in August and/or September.

    Ron

  6. #456
    Quote Originally Posted by gcpursuit View Post
    I am not sure how this future start date will pan out. What I read is that USCIS will only start working on the EAD application after COS is approved. Even if we do apply on May 26 without wasting any time, I was thinking that both COS and getting EAD may not be possible within 5 months.

    I will wait to hear others thoughts on this.
    jimmys,

    I checked with my attorney on the future start date. They dont think its possible to do that for H4 application.

  7. #457
    Pandit
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    Location
    Sunny SoCal
    Posts
    108
    Quote Originally Posted by gcpursuit View Post
    jimmys,

    I checked with my attorney on the future start date. They dont think its possible to do that for H4 application.
    Alright man, thanks.

  8. #458
    Pandit
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    Location
    Sunny SoCal
    Posts
    108
    After AILA's latest meeting, what would be latest that dates can go this year? Will it be Sep 2009???

  9. #459

    COD Advancement in Q4

    Jimmys, as Gurus have estimated it will be difficult for even May 2009 PD Folks to get their GC this year.
    However the key question is to what extent the Cut Off Date will advance ( Albeit temporarily) towards the end of 2015.

    It would be great if it could go up to Sep 2009 . However the real answer will come on Jun 12th with the July 2015 bulletin. Lets say it goes up to Jun or Jul 2009 in that bulletin. From that point we will see minimal movement.
    Just like you i am eagerly awaiting the next two bulletins which will determine this year.

    Lets see if our superusers and predictors chime in to give their estimates about the COD advancement.

    Quote Originally Posted by jimmys View Post
    After AILA's latest meeting, what would be latest that dates can go this year? Will it be Sep 2009???

  10. #460
    Last year April inventory came in around May 13th. Looks like the June bulletin and April inventory come out around the same time. Back to hibernation.

  11. #461
    Thanks titha1 and Spectator.

    @titha1: It seems change of status takes a long time. We are going for consular processing. Keeping our finger crossed.

    @Spectator: You bought a very good point. We are aware of the 2 year HRR. However, getting residency is so hard. We are just kicking the can down the road

  12. #462
    In the last couple of months, I have been getting more involved in my immigration related topics (I should have been more involved before) and this forum have been extremely helpful (thanks to folks who have contributed excellent insights).

    Just to give a brief background . .I have EB3 I140 Approved (PD 09/2009) and I have applied for EB2 PERM (12/2013). I did not realize it initially but when I looked at the PERM documents couple of days back, I found that the job description is almost the same (except for 2 additional sentence). The job title is different (Analyst vs Manager), the experience required is Bachelor + 2 for the first one and Bachelors + 5 / Masters +2 for the second one and of course the salary. I am not using any internal experience. Do you think it is will create problem while applying for EB2 I140 or at any later point in the process? I have heard from multiple sources that job description needs to be more than 50% different but my job description was so generic. Any insights will be greatly appreciated.

  13. #463
    Guru Spectator's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    A Galaxy Far far Away
    Posts
    3,337
    My understanding is that the 50%+ difference is only relevant where the person needs to use experience with the current employer to meet the petition requirements.

    My understanding of your post is that you already had the required Education/Experience requirements for the position at the time you joined your employer. If so, I don't foresee a problem with that aspect.

    I would bow to other answers from people with more experience of this type of situation.
    Without an irritant, there can be no pearl.

  14. #464
    Spectator: Thanks a lot for your prompt response. Won't UCSIS/govt agency ask why the job description is very similar but have different experience requirement. Also, my title has changed again slightly from Manager to Senior Manager. I am not sure if it is going to impact the process. I heard that it should not change since my responsibilities are almost same and it is just a small change in title.

    I had MS+ 2 years experience before I joined the company. Since the job description requires either a Bachelor + 5 years or MS + 2, the lawyer mentioned that I do not need to use my current employers experience.

  15. #465
    Guru Spectator's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    A Galaxy Far far Away
    Posts
    3,337
    Quote Originally Posted by unknownindian1 View Post
    Spectator: Thanks a lot for your prompt response. Won't UCSIS/govt agency ask why the job description is very similar but have different experience requirement. Also, my title has changed again slightly from Manager to Senior Manager. I am not sure if it is going to impact the process. I heard that it should not change since my responsibilities are almost same and it is just a small change in title.

    I had MS+ 2 years experience before I joined the company. Since the job description requires either a Bachelor + 5 years or MS + 2, the lawyer mentioned that I do not need to use my current employers experience.
    I agree with your lawyer.

    I can't comment on your other question.
    Without an irritant, there can be no pearl.

  16. #466
    Hi all, I need some advise on what should I do to get an update on my pending 485. Any help is greatly appreciated. Below are my details:

    COB: India
    EB3 priority date: October 1st 2004 (labor substitution)
    I-485 filed: August 2007 at Nebraska Service Center (was residing in CA)
    EB2 I-140 filed: December 2014 at Nebraska Service Center
    I-485 transferred to Texas Service Center January 2015 (maybe because I am in CO now)
    Spouse I-485 Filed: January 2015 at Phoenix lockbox, and was sent to TSC
    EB2 I-140 approved: February 3rd 2015 with old EB3 priority date of October 1st 2004; same day spouse I-485 was accepted at TSC; finger print notice received for spouse, finger print completed, received EAD and AP for spouse in March 2015

    However since then there has been no update on my I-485 application. I opened 4 service requests since Feb 2015, 2 infopass appointments, contacted local congressman, but unable to get any update. I also emailed EBUPDATE.tsc@dhs.gov and TSC.NCSCfollowup@uscis.dhs.gov 3 weeks ago and no response. Please let me know what I should do to get an update.

    Thanks,
    cbames

  17. #467
    Guru Spectator's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    A Galaxy Far far Away
    Posts
    3,337
    cbames,

    I think you have probably done what you can, but your expectations seem a little optimistic.

    It seems to take an average of about 6-7 months from the approval of the EB2 I-140 to receive an I-485 approval for porting cases.

    I had a quick look at early PD approvals on Trackitt and with a few exceptions, USCIS have been approving cases where the I-140 was approved in the July-October 2014 range. There are outliers at both ends of that range. There is 1 case of an I-485 approval from a March 2015 I-140 approval.

    Your EB2 I-140 was approved about 84 days ago. Unless you get lucky, you should expect to wait a while longer yet.

    In addition, the INA states that the order of consideration for an I-485 is based on the date the petition (I-140) was received by USCIS (INA 203(c)).

    INA: ACT 203 - ALLOCATION OF IMMIGRANT VISAS

    (e) Order of Consideration. -

    (1) Immigrant visas made available under subsection (a) or (b) shall be issued to eligible immigrants in the order in which a petition in behalf of each such immigrant is filed with the Attorney General (or in the case of special immigrants under section 101(a)(27)(D) , with the Secretary of State) as provided in section 204(a).
    Subsection (b) refers to 203(b) - Preference Allocation for Employment-Based Immigrants. A petition refers to the I-140 for EB1-EB3.

    Although you have an early PD date, your qualifying EB2 petition was only received by USCIS in December 2014. That means many cases that are current will have a petition receipt date earlier than yours.

    Hard as it may be, I think you need to temper your expectations at this time and be delighted if the approval comes earlier.
    Without an irritant, there can be no pearl.

  18. #468
    Thank you very much Spectator. I just checked and my EB2 I-140 was received by USCIS on 12/5/2014. How long do you think it might take for USCIS to look into my 485? Also is there anything I can do to make sure my 485 will be considered under EB2, and not EB3.

    Thanks,
    cbames

  19. #469
    CO's website folks are getting a bit sloppy. The current bulletin being shown is April and next month is May!!
    I no longer provide calculations/predictions ever since whereismyGC.com was created.
    I do run this site only as an administrator. Our goal is to improve clarity of GC process to help people plan their lives better.
    Use the info at your risk. None of this is legal advice.

    Forum Glossary | Forum Rules and Guidelines | If your published post disappeared, check - Lies and Misinformation thread


  20. #470
    Hi Spectator, my congressman's office just got this response from the TSC regarding my I-485:

    “The I-485 (LIN08xxxx/Axxxx) employment-based petition is based on the approved I-140 (LIN15xxxx) which was given a 2nd preference category from India with a priority date of 10/01/2004 so there is a current visa. The file is currently in transit to another liaison so it will be assigned to the Adjudication Unit for review once the file is received. The FBI fingerprints have expired but the name checks are valid. Once the review is completed, the individual should receive a Notice of Action regarding the case.”

    Thanks,
    cbames

  21. #471

  22. #472
    Shouldn't the April 2015 Inventory Report for Pending I-485 be out by now?
    EB2I PD: 08/23/2010 | NBC : MSC21903****
    I-485 RD: 10/28/2020 | ND: 12/08/2020 | FP: 03/02/2021 | Approved: 09/22/2021
    I-485J ND: 08/11/2021 | Approved: 09/22/2021
    I-693 RFE: 08/30/2021 (Fom local FO) - RFER 09/15/2021
    I-765, I-131 RD: 12/18/2020 | FP: 03/15/2021 | Exp. Request 07/21/2021 - Humanitarian Reason (07/28/2021 - Assigned to officer) | Approval: pending
    I-485 New card production: 9/18/2021
    I-485 Approval: 9/22/2021
    Green card mailed: 9/22/2021
    Green card received : 9/24/2021

  23. #473
    Oh Well... status quo continues. Only 5.5 months this time for EB2I. Next month will be the important one a we will enter 4th quarter.
    EB3ROW continues to resist becoming current. Going from 01Jan2015 to 15Feb2015 makes no difference to anything at all.
    EB2C made a big inventory building jump of 1 year.
    All the missing demand in EB3P has come back with a vengeance.
    Quote Originally Posted by surya1975 View Post
    EB2I NSC | PD: 08/07/2009 | Forum Glossary

  24. #474
    Quote Originally Posted by imdeng View Post
    Oh Well... status quo continues. Only 5.5 months this time for EB2I. Next month will be the important one a we will enter 4th quarter.
    EB3ROW continues to resist becoming current. Going from 01Jan2015 to 15Feb2015 makes no difference to anything at all.
    EB2C made a big inventory building jump of 1 year.
    All the missing demand in EB3P has come back with a vengeance.
    disappointing, I don't know the point to keep moving EB3ROW a month instead of make it current and start moving EB3I
    EB3ROW is current since couple of months now and i don't see any data that can tell me there are any surprise.
    The only thing i can think of is that they have already good inventory for EB3I until this PDs, anything else is just nonsense.

  25. #475
    Pandit
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    Location
    Sunny SoCal
    Posts
    108
    Quote Originally Posted by gten20 View Post
    Shouldn't the April 2015 Inventory Report for Pending I-485 be out by now?
    Should most likely be out this week.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 6 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 6 guests)

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •